Helen LonginoStudying Human Behavior: How Scientists Investigate Aggression & Sexuality

University of Chicago Press, 2013

by Carrie Figdor on May 15, 2013

Helen Longino

View on Amazon

What explains human behavior? It is standard to consider answers from the perspective of a dichotomy between nature and nurture, with most researchers today in agreement that it is both. For Helen Longino, Clarence Irving Lewis Professor of Philosophy at Stanford University, the “both” answer misses the fact that the nature/nurture divide is itself problematic. In her groundbreaking book, Studying Human Behavior: How Scientists Investigate Aggression & Sexuality (University of Chicago Press) Longino looks closely at a variety of scientific approaches to the study of human aggression and sexuality to argue that there is no one right way to divide nature from nurture within the scientific approaches to the study of behavior, and that the nature/nurture dichotomy reinforces and reflects an undue emphasis on explanations that focus on the dispositions of individuals rather than those that look at patterns of frequency and distribution of behavior within populations. She reveals the distinct and incompatible ways these different approaches define the factors that explain behavior, how these different explanatory approaches are related, and how the bias towards particular types of explanation is reflected in the way the scientific findings are publicly disseminated.

{ 0 comments }

Philip PettitOn The People’s Terms: A Republican Theory and Model of Democracy

May 1, 2013

In political philosophy, republicanism is the name of a distinctive framework for thinking about politics. At its core is a unique conception of freedom according to which freedom consists in non-domination, that is, in not having a master or lord, in not being subject to the arbitrary will of another.  This republican conception of the [...]

Read the full article →

Meir Hemmo and Orly ShenkerThe Road to Maxwell’s Demon: Conceptual Foundations of Statistical Mechanics

April 15, 2013

Among the very many puzzling aspects of the physical world is this: how do we explain the fact that the laws of thermodynamics are time-asymmetric while those of statistical mechanics are time-symmetric? If the fundamental physical laws do not require events to occur in any particular temporal direction, why do we observe a world in [...]

Read the full article →

Cheryl MisakThe American Pragmatists

April 1, 2013

Pragmatism is American’s home-grown philosophy, but it is not widely understood.  This partly is due to the fact that pragmatism emerged out of deep philosophical disputes among its earliest proponents: Charles Sanders Peirce, William James, and John Dewey.  Although it is agreed that they are the founders of Pragmatism, they also held opposing views about [...]

Read the full article →

Jesse J. PrinzThe Conscious Brain: How Attention Engenders Experience

March 15, 2013

For decades now, philosophers, linguists, psychologists and neuroscientists have been working to understand the nature of the hard-to-describe but very familiar conscious experiences we have while awake. Some have thought consciousness can’t be explained scientifically, and others have argued that it will always remain a mystery. But most consider some sort of explanation in physical, [...]

Read the full article →

Roslyn WeissPhilosophers in the Republic: Plato’s Two Paradigms

March 1, 2013

Contemporary philosophers still wrestle mightily with Plato’s Republic. A common reading has it that in the Republic, Plato’s character Socrates defends a conception of justice according to which reason should rule the soul and philosophers should rule the city.  On all accounts, the Republic is centrally concerned with the question of what philosophers are and [...]

Read the full article →

Beth PrestonA Philosophy of Material Culture: Action, Function, and Mind

February 15, 2013

Many philosophers have written on the ways in which human beings produce artifacts and on the nature of artifacts themselves, often distinguishing the act of producing or making from growing, and distinguishing artifacts from natural objects. However, such discussions have tended to be theoretically restrictive – for example, in philosophy of technology, the focus is [...]

Read the full article →

Clayton LittlejohnJustification and the Truth-Connection

February 1, 2013

There is a long-standing debate in epistemology between internalists and externalists about justification.  Internalists think that a belief is justified in virtue of certain facts internal to the believer.  Externalists deny this; they hold that facts of some other kind must obtain in order for a belief to be justified.  In his new book, Justification [...]

Read the full article →

Herman CappelenPhilosophy Without Intuitions

January 15, 2013

It’s taken for granted among analytic philosophers that some of their primary areas of inquiry – ethics, epistemology, philosophy of mind and philosophy of language, in particular – involve a special and characteristic methodology that depends essentially on the use of intuitions as evidence for philosophical positions. A thought experiment is developed in order to [...]

Read the full article →

Brian LeiterWhy Tolerate Religion?

January 3, 2013

Religious conviction enjoys a privileged status in our society.  This is perhaps most apparent in legal contexts, where religious conviction is often given special consideration.  To be more precise, religious conscience is recognized as a legitimate basis for exemption from standing laws, whereas claims of conscience deriving from non-religious commitments generally are not.  Why is [...]

Read the full article →