Michael StrevensTychomancy: Inferring Probability from Causal Structure

Harvard University Press, 2013

by Carrie Figdor on April 15, 2014

Michael Strevens

View on Amazon

When we’re faced with a choice between Door #1, Door #2, and Door #3, how do we infer correctly that there’s an equal chance of the prize being behind any of the doors? How is it that we are generally correct to choose the shorter of two checkout lines in the supermarket when we’re in a hurry? In his new book, Tychomancy: Inferring Probability from Causal Structure (Harvard University Press, 2013), Michael Strevens – professor of philosophy at New York University, argues that we are all equipped with a reliable, probable innate, and not fully conscious skill at probabilistic reasoning — a “physical intuition” that enables us to infer physical probabilities from perceived symmetries. This skill is found in six-month-old infants watching as red and white balls are removed in different proportions from an urn. But it also underlies important advances in the sciences, such as James Clerk Maxwell’s reasoning when he hit upon the correct distribution of velocities of a moving particle in a gas. In this intriguing essay on a very special type of cognitive capacity, Strevens defends controversial claims about the rules guiding our reasoning about physical probability, its probable innateness, and its role in science as well as in everyday judgment.


Adrienne MartinHow We Hope: A Moral Psychology

April 1, 2014

From political campaigns to sports stadiums and hospital rooms, the concept of hope is pervasive.  And the story we tend to tell ourselves about hope is that it is intrinsically a good thing — in many ways we still tend to think of hope as a kind of virtue.  Hence we talk about hopes being [...]

Read the full article →

Josef SternThe Matter and Form of Maimonides’ Guide

March 14, 2014

The medieval Jewish scholar Moses Maimonides’ most famous work, The Guide of the Perplexed, has been interpreted variously as an attempt to reconcile reason and religion, as a guide to philosophers on ruling the community while concealing the truth, or as an exegesis of rabbinical texts. In The Matter and Form of Maimonides’ Guide (Harvard University Press, [...]

Read the full article →

David EdmondsWould You Kill the Fat Man?

March 1, 2014

The trolley problem is a staple of contemporary moral philosophy.  It centers around two scenarios involving a runaway trolley.  In the first, a trolley is barreling down a track without any brakes; off in the distance five people are tied to the track.  If you do nothing, they will be killed by the trolley.  But [...]

Read the full article →

Sarah PessinIbn Gabirol’s Theology of Desire: Matter and Method in Jewish Medieval Neoplatonism

February 15, 2014

Neoplatonists, including the 11th century Jewish philosopher-poet Solomon Ibn Gabirol, are often saddled with a cosmology considered either as outdated science or a kind of “invisible floating Kansas” in which spatiotemporal talk isn’t really about space or time. Sarah Pessin, Associate Professor of Philosophy and the Emil and Eva Hecht Chair in Judaic Studies at the [...]

Read the full article →

Joseph CarensThe Ethics of Immigration

February 1, 2014

It is commonly assumed that states have a right to broad discretionary control over immigration, and that they may decide almost in any way they choose, who may stay within the territory and who must leave.  But even supposing that there is such a right, we may ask the decidedly moral question about how it [...]

Read the full article →

Michael WeisbergSimulation and Similarity: Using Models to Understand the World

January 15, 2014

In 1956 and 1957, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers decided to test a plan to dam up the San Francisco Bay in order to protect its water supply: they built a 1.5 acre model of the Bay area in a warehouse, with hydraulic pumps to simulate tides and river flows, and observed the result. [...]

Read the full article →

Michael HuemerThe Problem of Political Authority: An Examination of the Right to Coerce and the Duty to Obey

January 1, 2014

The philosopher Robert Nozick once claimed that the most basic question of Political Philosophy is “Why not Anarchy?”  Political philosophers pose this question often with the intent of demonstrating that there is indeed a good philosophical reason why governments should exist.  Indeed, we often simply take for granted that the state and its vast coercive [...]

Read the full article →

Jennifer A. McMahonArt and Ethics in a Material World: Kant’s Pragmatist Legacy

December 15, 2013

Art and ethics are linked philosophically by the fact that they are both fall under value theory; and some aestheticians, notably Berys Gaut, have argued for a direct connection between aesthetic and moral values, in that the moral values that an artwork may embody can raise or lower its aesthetic value. In Art and Ethics [...]

Read the full article →

R. Jay WallaceThe View from Here: On Affirmation, Attachment, and the Limits of Regret

December 1, 2013

Our moral lives are shot-through with concerns and even anxieties about the past.  Only a lucky few, if anyone at all, can escape nagging and persistent regrets about actions and decisions in our past.  But sometimes those very decisions that we now regret are the causal or conceptual antecedents of subsequent outcomes that we now [...]

Read the full article →